Last Updated on August 27, 2023

Originally published in the North Bethesda Camera Club Lens and Eye Newsletter for August 2023.

©Gloria Davis
As it turns out, the critique classes I took with Roy Sewell both enhanced my own photography and provided a model for a photo club I would launch in my Catonsville, MD retirement community. The perfect combination for me was the one-on-one critique, the non-competitive atmosphere and, of course, Roy’s detailed system of determining what makes a good photo.

I decided to start the Photography Interest Group (PHIG) at the Charlestown Retirement Community to see if there was an interest. With nearly 2,000 residents in a community that embraces lifelong learning and fosters an atmosphere of vibrant living, I thought it was time to test the waters. I invited all with an interest in photography, and any level of experience or gear. I purposely chose to emphasize composition as a way to make it inviting and accessible to all.

Five years later, we have 45+ members. Meeting monthly, we use Roy’s methodology for critiquing photos and determining what would make a photo more impactful.

As the chief evaluator and a visual learner, I have developed a system of live critiquing, displaying post processing steps on a 90 inch monitor. I have used both the iPhoto editing tool that is built into my iPad, and the mobile Lightroom app. It is a powerful way to illustrate editing choices and engage members in offering their own suggestions. The interactive method encourages learning, with a surprisingly high degree of consensus on the final image.

Members’ images are displayed after each meeting on the residents’ website which is open to the public. We also hold an annual exhibition of members’ photos in the community Gallery in collaboration with the Charlestown artists.

One additional benefit we have discovered is the value of members sharing the stories behind their photos. With a rich lifetime of travel experiences, personal journeys and unforgettable moments, it is good to have a chance to discuss them with an audience of receptive peers.

– Betty Caldwell, Member

© John Chasse